The Big Confrontation: Esau & Jacob Meet after 20 Years

 

by Simon Jacobson
November 29, 2012

Jacob remained alone. A man wrestled with him until dawn
– This week’s Torah portion, Genesis 32:25

During the night of Exile, the nations of the world and the kingdom of Edom (Esau) wrestle with Jacob, until the dawn of redemption
– Midrash Lekach Tov on the verse

Esau told Jacob: I will travel alongside you. My lord you know that the children are weak and I have responsibility for the nursing sheep and cattle. If they are driven hard for even one day, they will die…Please go ahead of me… I will lead my group slowly, following the pace of the work ahead of me, and the pace of the children. I will eventually come to you, my lord, in Seir [Edom]
- Genesis 33:12-13

And when will he [Jacob] go [to Seir]? In the days of Moshiach, as it says (Ovadiah 1:21) Redeemers will ascend Mount Zion to judge the Mount of Esau, and the kingdom will be G-d’s
- Rashi

The stage is set. Jacob is returning to Israel after 20 years of exile. Twenty years previously he fled from his brother Esau who, furious at the fact that Jacob “stole” his birthright and blessings from him, wanted to kill him. During his years in exile, Jacob built a strong home and large family. He matured extensively during his twenty year tenure under his complex and cunning uncle and father-in-law, Laban.

The big day has come. What will happen when Jacob meets Esau after all these years? Has Esau’s anger waned? Has he forgiven what Jacob did to him?

Jacob and Esau represent “two nations” in a perpetual struggle (see Jacob and Esau: Two Nations) – the battle between matter and spirit, between body and soul, between the G-dly and the mundane, between religion and science, between the religious and the secular. In personal terms – the battle between selfishness and dedication to a higher calling.

What happens when Esau and Jacob finally confront each other? What does it teach us about dealing with our own challenges, our own version of the Jacob/Esau confrontation? Can peace be achieved between matter and spirit, body and soul – G-d and the universe?

So, this week’s parsha is a critical one being that in it we learn about this momentous/archetypal confrontation, which teaches us about all confrontations to come – up to and including the confrontations of our present today.

Many lessons can be derived from this week’s story in dealing with and conquering adversity. Here are some of them.

ASSESS THE SITUATION

Before confronting Esau Jacob first sends messengers to scout out what lies ahead and to meet Esau. The first step in facing an adversary is to understand their intentions, assess their strengths and review all your options.

SPIRITUAL PREPARATION

You must be well prepared. Jacob’s message to Esau was: “I have lived with Laban, and have delayed my return until now.” Even while living with the corrupt Laban “I remained committed to the 613 mitzvahs,” and maintained my relationship with G-d. Jacob’s words teach us that before facing the harsh realities of life we must build a secure home base, firmly standing on the pillars and foundations of faith, spirit and a strong value system and ideals.

INFLUENCE PEOPLE

The only way to complete the transformation of the material world is by imbuing others with energy to carry the spirit further. Our work in refining the “Esau’s” and “Edom’s” of our life includes inspiring others to become ‘messengers’ that carry the power. It is not enough to do the work alone; the barometer of our own success is our ability to affect and influence others in the same spirit. We are social creatures; our lives affect and are affected by other people. In life you have two and only two choices: Either you influence others or they influence you.

COVER ALL BASES

Jacob prepares to face Esau by covering all his bases: He prays to G-d; he prepares gifts to appease him; and he prepares for battle.

Prayer: Speak to G-d and implore Him to help you. Faith and prayer connect you to your higher purpose. This connection to above gives you the fortitude and persistence to face any challenge, the confidence to face any adversary.

Appeasement: When confronting any challenge in the material world around us, it is critical to study and analyze the ‘enemy’ and learn what ‘speaks’ to it, what can reach and perhaps change his mind.

War: As a last resort you must prepare to fight the enemy.

The ultimate objective is not to destroy but to transform the enemy. Not to annihilate the material world but to shape it into a channel for the spiritual. To do so effectively, you need to begin with prayer, to access G-d’s strength to succeed in your facing your challenges. Then you need to assess the challenge and find a way to win it over, to speak to and persuade it on its own terms to reconcile with you. Finally, if all else fails you must be ready to go to war and confront your enemy.

NOTHING IS TOO SMALL

In preparation for encountering Esau the following day, Jacob ferries his family across the Yabbok stream, but he remains behind “alone,” to retrieve some "small jars" of his that were left behind. There, "a man wrestled with him until dawn."

The “small jars” represent the last ‘containers’ that we need to elevate and refine in fulfilling our Divine mission in spiritualizing the material world. Each person is allocated an allotment of ‘Divine ‘sparks’ (spiritual energy) that is embedded – as energy in ‘containers’ – in our material possessions and property. Everything that comes your way in life contains these ‘sparks’ – your home, relationships, furniture, work, car, food, entertainment, activities, travel destinations. You are charged with the responsibility to discover and reveal these sparks by directing all your activities to a higher, spiritual purpose.

Jacob teaches us that our work must not only consist of the ‘big things’ in life, it must include all aspects, even the ‘small jars.’ Nothing should remain neglected. Every part of our lives can and needs to be redeemed.

“Jacob remained alone.” – The spiritual journey is often a lonely one. At times you may feel that you are all alone in your work of redeeming the ‘small jars.’ People around you may be involved in all types of glamorous pursuits, and you could feel isolated in your spiritual search. Your search may pale in comparison to what’s ‘happening’ out there. Even then you must remain steadfast in your mission. Your integrity is at stake even when its unpopular.

YOU ARE NOT ALONE

The spiritual journey is often a lonely one. It includes many challenges and battles. Standing alone you will encounter forces with which you must wrestle. And this wrestling will occur during the night, when it is dark and desolate, as Jacob wrestles with Esau’s angel. This “wrestling” represents the cosmic struggle between matter and spirit, and Jacob’s victory empowers us to prevail over any adversary we face.

In truth, you are never really alone. It only appears that way especially in the cover of night. When you wrestle with an adversary and don’t run away, you realize that you have power. Sometimes that power is just enough to make it through the night, to see it through difficult times. But then when dawn breaks, you see that you have prevailed.

RECONCILIATION

Indeed, the next day when Jacob finally meets Esau, Esau’s heart opens to his brother. “Esau ran to meet him. He hugged [Jacob] and throwing himself on his shoulders, kissed him. They [both] wept.”

After all Jacob’s work and preparation for this encounter with Esau – his 20 years with Laban, building is home and family, his prayer and gifts, his angel wrestling – he is able to face him and reconcile. The two nations and worlds, the two cosmic forces that are Esau and Jacob, have both matured to the point where they can begin to coexist with each other.

The sages argue whether or not this was a complete and sincere reconciliation. The argument reflects the difficulty of integrating the two. Either way the process of resolution between matter and spirit has begun.

THE WORK AHEAD

Witnessing their reunion, Esau suggests to Jacob that they come together and join forces. However Jacob wisely recognizes that their reunion was only a good beginning. “My lord you know that the children are weak and I have responsibility for the nursing sheep and cattle. If they are driven hard for even one day, they will die… Please go ahead of me… I will lead my group slowly, following the pace of the work ahead of me, and the pace of the children. I will eventually come to you, my lord, in Seir.”

Jacob is telling Esau and all of us that there is much work to be done in resolving the inherent tension between the material and the spiritual. And this work must be done with complete focus. Jacob rejects even Esau’s offer to help by putting “some of my people at your disposal,” even that poses too great of a risk. “Just let me remain on friendly terms with you,” Jacob tells Esau.

Today, after 3568 years of work, the world has become refined and the reconciliation can be completed. Jacob can finally fulfill his promise to Esau, “I will eventually come to you,” and the world can be united under one G-d, with each nation serving in its own unique way.

Each of us must ask ourselves the question: Is my ‘Jacob’ ready to meet and make peace with my ‘Esau’? Is my material life aligned with my spiritual one? Have I integrated what I do with who I am?

The final frontier is upon us. As Esau, Jacob, Ishmael confront each other, they are challenged to embrace the G-d of their father Abraham – a G-d who wants to be at peace with the universe. A peace that can only be achieved when we do our part in revealing the G-dliness in everything we do.

And so this week’s Torah portion closes the chapter of Esau. Just as the portion of Chayei Sarah concludes with the chronicles of Ishmael, and the portion of Toldot concludes with Esau’s marriage to Ishmael’s daughter, this week’s portion concludes with the chronicles of Esau. It details Esau’s family line and the leaders and nations that would descend from him, concluding with Magdiel, founder of Rome.

The seeds have been planted for the confrontations to come. The question today is: Do we understand the message?

 



Share
Abraham's Vision: Tracing the Roots of Today's Global Conflict
Absolute Passion in the Face of Complacency
Flooding the World with Divine Knowledge
How to Treat Infidels
Ishmael: How Does it End?
Jacob's Ladder: The Rise & Fall of Nations
Jacob Never Dies
Joseph's Treasure: The Refinement Process Begins
Joseph & Marx: The Continuing Story of Today's Events
Renewal not just Survival
The Big Confrontation: Esau & Jacob Meet after Years
The Birth of Hope
The Plot Thickens: Esau & Jacob - Two Nations
The Power of Joy Amidst Uncertainty
The Selling of Joseph: Peace at Home - Key to World Peace
Today the World Trembles Today the World is Born

 



Visitor Comments
Edith Ognall, 11/30/2012
Absolutely, Israel’s existence does not depend on the UN or any other organization.
Unfortunately it is Israel itself with its weak and faithless Leaders that is bringing Israel constant deligitimization with its surrender and concession policies towards our enemies, boosting and supporting our enemies and uprooting our own people from their homes and land. Handing over the Temple Mount and taking down the Israeli Flag ordered by Dayan after the reliberation of Yerushalayim and the subsequent surrender of all our holy sites to the Muslims only gives more reason to an increasingly hostile world to believe that we really don’t belong here. The Arabs don’t surrender and don’t make concessions so it would seem reasonable we are the usurpers and they the true owners. If our own prime minister acknowledges to the world that the fake palestinians have a legitimate claim to our land and deserve their own state in Judea and Samaria with hundreds of thousands of Jews once again being dispossessed, what do we expect. We are full partners in this venture with Hashem and we don’t play our part. Too many of our people think all we have to do is leave it up to our Father in Heaven and all will be well. That is not how it works but getting the people to acknowledge the truth is difficult.
Shabbat Shalom
Edith Ognall
Netanya
Chuck Stern, 11/30/2012
Why we are not taught of Esau's time
The Torah is interesting in what it leaves out as much as what it includes, William. While you make some good points about Esau having been a success, and about him being the first to run and embrace his brother, think about what the Torah is and isn't.

The Torah is not a history book. The Torah is equally not a book of laws. The Torah IS a spiritual and emotional roadmap of the Jewish people. So why leave Esau's travails and journeys out? Esau's life, as seen in other places, is devoted simply to material gain - the acquisition of temporal power, the acquisition of wealth no matter the spiritual cost. Yaakov's life, in contrast, is devoted to G-d and family. His material success is a side effect of his devotion to that which is really important.

So when Jacob refers to Esau as "adoni," my lord, he is showing respect for his physical and material success, simultaneously asking him to raise his spiritual aspects, which are considerable. When Esau refers to Jacob as "achi," my brother, he is in a sense asking Jacob to lower himself spiritually to Esau's level, and also in a sense recognizing that the sum of their successes is equal.

And consider this - when Jacob says that his path must needs be slower than Esau's, you might want to consider it in the light of the story told by Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chanania in Eruvin - the path that Esau wishes to take is the short long way - he has great monetary gains, but is going to hit a spirtual wall. Jacob's path is the long short way; his path to material success is longer, because he does not choose the route of success at all costs.

William Stafford, 12/13/2011
Esau is this stuck?
I have read this passage regarding J and E again and again to the point I have memorized it. I am awestruck that we have such a wealth of information regarding Jacob but such a pawcity relative to Esau.

Still we have information. 20 years elapse. The information on Jacob is everywhere, e.g. family, wives, children, work, etc. Esau's life is basically, no, absolutely not divulged during this time.

Esau knew where Jacob was headed. Esau was a skillful hunter and could easily have tracked Jacob down but does not.

Jacob sends messengers to Esau. The messengers return to Jacob. If Esau had still harbored such resentment why would he allow the messengers to return at all? Why inform the messengers that Esau was coming with 400 men, if Esau meant harm? Does a hunter, i.e. military man, expose his position, strength, etc? I don't think so. Yet Esau has done this very thing. Not a bit of ruse seems involved with Esau.

Jacob knows his brother is coming and with other men.

What alarms me is that Jacob does not consider alternatives as to Esau's motives. He immediately returns to the mindset and emotions he had some 20 years previously. These are that Esau meant to do him harm and probably still does. These are his initial reactions.

What does he think Esau will do with the information of him coming back to Seir when he sends the messengers? If he considered Esau as any type of adversary or threat, why send the messengers in the first place?

Amazingly, Esau upon seeing Jacob is the one to run to embrace Jacob.

Even more amazing is that Esau addresses Jacob as "brother" while Jacob refers to Esau as either Lord or Master. Jacob constantly refers to himself as the servant of Esau. This is astonishing!

Even more astonising is that it is Esau who reinstates the brother relationship between Jacob and himself. Esau does not want or as he states need what Jacob has proffered.

The following dialogue in Chapter 33:

Esau asked Jacob, “What’s the meaning of all these flocks and herds I met?”

Jacob to Esau “To find favor in your eyes, my lord,” he said.

But Esau said to Jacob, “I already have plenty, my brother. Keep what you have for yourself.”

Evidence that Esau has in some fashion achieved some measure of influence or degree of success is the very fact that 400 men accompany him. Regardless of whether the men are friends, compatriots, or compelled, e.g. conscripted, they accompany Esau to meet his brother.

Esau is this simple? Perhaps that is the lesson we need to take. Esau seems to have done what his mother Rebecca stated would happen. The anger and fury within Esau dissipates. When did it dissipate? It may very well have been within a few days or perhaps longer, but it seems clear from the passage that Esau's anger has been completely replaced with the love for his brother Jacob and what had occurred earlier, much earlier has long been put to the side.

Who then is constantly aware or reminded of Esau's anger, even if such is or has become only a memory to be dusted off as necessary?

Is Esau used to justify not moving on?

I'll have to read more but I like that Esau after having not chased down his brother following the blessing activity, embraces his brother after so long an absence, offered to accompany him and his belongings, and even to have offered to have men stay with Jacob as he journeyed, eventually moves on back to Seir.

It seems that Jacob can't forget.

I can offer help but to just sit waiting for such to be taken/accepted is rather a waste.

I like Esau.

I like that Esau just moves on.

Esau like Jacob was over 60 years of age when this encounter took place. Isn't that evidence of a Esau's maturity to offer but not insist that his help be taken? Esau accepts that Jacob too has grown and is capable of making his own decisions. Esau honors and respects this and does not insist on accompanying or assisting Jacob.

I approach this age. I think back on some of the crap I learned growing up. I realize now how much of it was just that: crap.

I do think of this and how it was taught to me as a younger person. Esau the crude boorish man. Jacob the favored and refined. What a load!

It has taken some knocks to make it such that I do not see Esau in such light. I am thankful to G_d for this. Esau's restiveness may well be rising.

Eric S. Kingston, 11/17/2005
The Struggle
Keep the faith. Continue to study. Live in the here, and now as your remember your past.
  

Google
Web Meaningfullife.com